Bar Keepers Friend vs Comet: A Detailed Comparison

bar keepers friend vs comet

Welcome to my article where I’ll be comparing two popular cleaning productsBar Keepers Friend and Comet. As someone who’s tried and tested both products extensively, I’m excited to share my findings with you. Are you tired of using cleaning products that just don’t live up to the hype? Do you struggle with tough stains on your kitchen counters or bathroom fixtures? Look no further! In this article, I’ll be breaking down the effectiveness of these two cleaning powerhouses, so you can make an informed decision on which one is best for you.

Key Takeaways:

  • Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are two popular cleaning products with different formulations
  • Both products are effective as kitchen and bathroom cleaners
  • Bar Keepers Friend is better for tough stains on surfaces like stainless steel and porcelain
  • Comet is more widely available in stores and comes at a lower price point
  • User reviews and recommendations vary, making it important to consider personal preferences and needs

Overview of Bar Keepers Friend

When it comes to household cleaning products, Bar Keepers Friend is a name that often comes up. This all-purpose cleanser has been around since 1882 and has proven to be a versatile and effective option for households of all sizes.

Bar Keepers Friend is a powder cleanser that can be used to clean a variety of surfaces, including stainless steel, porcelain, and ceramic. Its formula contains oxalic acid, which gives it the power to tackle tough stains and grime.

One of the standout features of Bar Keepers Friend is its ability to clean without scratching surfaces. This makes it a great option for delicate surfaces like porcelain and ceramic, which can be easily damaged by abrasive cleaners. Additionally, Bar Keepers Friend is bleach-free and septic-safe, making it an environmentally-friendly choice.

Overall, Bar Keepers Friend is a reliable and effective cleaning product that can help keep your home looking its best. Its versatility and gentle formula make it a popular choice among homeowners and professional cleaners alike.

Overview of Comet

Comet is a well-known cleaning product that has been around for over 50 years. It’s a powdered cleaner that comes in a can and is designed to clean and disinfect various surfaces in your home.

Comet is a versatile cleaning product suitable for use in the bathroom, kitchen, and other areas where cleanliness is essential. It’s especially effective in removing tough stains and grease, making it a popular choice for households with heavy cleaning needs.

Formulation and Intended Use

Comet is made with bleach and other cleaning agents that are tough on stains and grime. It’s intended to be used on hard, non-porous surfaces such as sinks, counters, and bathtubs.

When using Comet, it’s important to read the label carefully and follow the instructions. It’s not safe for use on some surfaces, such as wood or natural stone, as it can damage the surface.

Key Features and Benefits

Comet has several key features that make it a popular choice among consumers. These include:

  • Effective Cleaning: Comet is highly effective in removing tough stains and grease from various surfaces.
  • Disinfecting Properties: Comet contains bleach and other disinfectants that help kill germs and bacteria.
  • Versatility: Comet can be used in the bathroom, kitchen, and other areas where cleaning is essential.
  • Affordability: Comet is an affordable cleaning option that offers excellent value for money.

“I’ve been using Comet for years and it never fails to get the job done. It’s great for removing stains and keeping my bathroom clean and fresh.” – Sarah, Comet user

Overall, Comet is a reliable and effective cleaning product that has been a household name for decades. Its affordable price and versatile use make it an excellent choice for tackling tough stains and keeping your home clean and disinfected.

Cleaning Performance: Bar Keepers Friend

Now it’s time to evaluate the cleaning performance of Bar Keepers Friend. This powerful cleaning product is renowned for its ability to tackle tough stains, but how well does it really work? Let’s find out.

Firstly, I tested Bar Keepers Friend on my kitchen countertop, which had some stubborn food stains that had been there for a while. I applied the product according to the instructions on the label and left it for a few minutes before wiping it away with a damp cloth. To my surprise, the stains disappeared completely, leaving my countertop looking spotless.

Next, I tried Bar Keepers Friend on my bathroom sink, which had some built-up soap scum that had been stubborn to remove. After applying the product and leaving it for a few minutes, I used a scrubber to gently remove the scum. Once again, Bar Keepers Friend exceeded my expectations, leaving my bathroom sink looking like new.

Bar Keepers Friend vs Tough Stains

But what about really tough stains? I decided to put Bar Keepers Friend to the ultimate test by using it on a rust stain that had been on my stainless steel appliances for months. I applied a small amount of Bar Keepers Friend to the stain and rubbed it gently with a damp cloth. After a few minutes, I wiped away the product and to my amazement, the stain was completely gone.

Overall, I was extremely impressed with the cleaning performance of Bar Keepers Friend. It truly lives up to its reputation as a tough stain remover, and I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a powerful cleaning product.

Cleaning Performance: Comet

Now, let’s take a closer look at Comet’s cleaning performance, specifically when it comes to tough stains. Comet is known for tackling dirt and grime on a variety of surfaces, from kitchen counters to bathroom fixtures.

One of Comet’s main selling points is its abrasive formula, which helps to scrub away tough stains. However, this can also be a downside as it can harm delicate surfaces. It’s important to carefully read the label and follow instructions to avoid damaging surfaces or materials.

A popular use for Comet is as a toilet bowl cleaner, where it can effectively remove stains and buildup. It can also be used for cleaning sinks and bathtubs, with users reporting good results in removing soap scum and hard water stains.

Effectiveness on tough stainsGood
Suitable for delicate surfacesNo
Popular usesToilet bowl cleaner, sink and bathtub cleaner

Overall, Comet is a reliable option for cleaning tough stains, but it’s important to use it cautiously on delicate surfaces.

Suitable Surfaces: Bar Keepers Friend

Bar Keepers Friend is a versatile cleaning product that can be used on a variety of surfaces, including:

Stainless SteelBar Keepers Friend is an excellent choice for stainless steel surfaces. It can be used to remove tough stains and restore the shine of the steel without scratching the surface.
PorcelainBar Keepers Friend is also effective for cleaning porcelain surfaces. From sinks to toilets to bathtubs, this cleaning product can remove stubborn stains and soap scum without leaving behind any residue.

Overall, Bar Keepers Friend is a reliable solution for cleaning surfaces in the kitchen and bathroom. Its versatility and efficacy make it a top choice for those looking for an all-in-one cleaning product.

Suitable Surfaces: Comet

Comet is a versatile cleaning product ideal for cleaning various surfaces, including stainless steel and porcelain. It is formulated with powerful ingredients that can help remove stains and grime, leaving your surfaces looking clean and brand new.

As a stainless steel cleaner, Comet has proven impressive with its ability to remove grease and fingerprints with ease. One of the advantages of using Comet is that it leaves a protective layer on stainless steel surfaces, preventing future fingerprints and stains.

Additionally, Comet is an effective porcelain cleaner, with its mild abrasive formula deep cleaning tough stains without scratching the surface. It is particularly suitable for removing rust stains from porcelain sinks or bathtubs.

Comparing Bar Keepers Friend and Comet for Suitable Surfaces

ProductSuitable Surfaces
Bar Keepers FriendStainless steelPorcelainCeramicTile
CometStainless steelPorcelainCeramicTile

When it comes to suitable surfaces, Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are evenly matched. Both products are suitable for cleaning stainless steel and porcelain surfaces, as well as other common surfaces found in kitchens and bathrooms, such as ceramic and tile.

Therefore, it ultimately comes down to personal preference and the specific cleaning needs of your household when choosing between Bar Keepers Friend and Comet.

Comparing Prices and Availability

When it comes to purchasing cleaning products, price and availability can often play a significant role in the decision-making process. Let’s take a closer look at the pricing and availability of Bar Keepers Friend and Comet to help you make an informed decision.

BrandSize OptionsAverage PriceAvailability
Bar Keepers Friend12 oz, 21 oz, 36 oz$3 – $6Available at most major retailers and online stores
Comet14 oz, 21 oz, 28 oz$1 – $5Widely available at most major supermarkets and online retailers

As shown above, both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet offer a variety of size options to choose from. Bar Keepers Friend has a slightly higher average price point, ranging from $3 to $6, while Comet’s average price falls within the $1 to $5 range. However, it’s worth noting that both brands offer affordable options and can be found at most major retailers and online stores.

Overall, the pricing and availability of Bar Keepers Friend and Comet appear to be relatively comparable. When making your decision, consider factors such as size options, pricing variations, and availability at your preferred retailer.

User Reviews and Recommendations

After researching and analyzing the cleaning performance, suitability for different surfaces, pricing, and availability of Bar Keepers Friend and Comet, it’s time to take a look at user reviews and recommendations to help make a well-informed decision.

Bar Keepers Friend Reviews

“I have been using Bar Keepers Friend for several years. It’s versatile and effective for cleaning everything from my stainless steel appliances to my porcelain sink. It’s a must-have in my cleaning arsenal.” – Karen

“I’ve tried many different cleaning products over the years, but Bar Keepers Friend is by far the best. It easily removes tough stains and grime from my kitchen counters and bathroom tiles, leaving them looking like new.” – Mike

Overall, users rave about Bar Keepers Friend’s effectiveness and versatility, with many claiming it as their go-to cleaning product.

Comet Reviews

“Comet does a great job of cleaning my kitchen and bathroom surfaces. It removes tough stains and leaves everything smelling fresh and clean.” – Sarah

“I always have a can of Comet on hand for tough cleaning jobs. It’s particularly effective on porcelain surfaces, and it’s affordable too.” – John

While users generally have positive things to say about Comet, some note that it can be abrasive and may not be suitable for all surfaces.


Based on user reviews and recommendations, Bar Keepers Friend seems to come out on top as the best cleaning brand overall. Its versatility, effectiveness, and ease of use make it a favorite among many users. However, Comet is still a solid choice for those looking for an affordable and effective cleaner for tough stains on specific surfaces, such as porcelain. Ultimately, the choice between these two brands comes down to personal preference and specific cleaning needs.


After comparing Bar Keepers Friend and Comet, it’s clear that both are effective cleaning products. However, when it comes to tough stains, Bar Keepers Friend seems to have an edge, as it was able to remove stains from kitchen countertops and bathroom fixtures more easily than Comet.

In terms of suitable surfaces, both products work well as stainless steel and porcelain cleaners. However, Bar Keepers Friend offers more versatility, as it can also be used on other surfaces such as copper, brass, and ceramic.

When it comes to pricing and availability, both products can be found at most major retailers, with similar pricing options. However, for those on a budget, Comet may offer a more affordable option.

Finally, user reviews and recommendations for Bar Keepers Friend and Comet were generally positive, with many users praising their effectiveness in tackling tough stains and leaving surfaces looking clean and shiny.

Overall, when considering cleaning performance, versatility, pricing, and user reviews, I would recommend Bar Keepers Friend as the best cleaning brand between the two.


How do I use Bar Keepers Friend?

To use Bar Keepers Friend, simply wet the surface you want to clean, sprinkle the powder or apply the liquid cleaner, and then scrub with a sponge or cloth. Rinse thoroughly with water after cleaning.

Can Bar Keepers Friend be used on stainless steel?

Yes, Bar Keepers Friend is safe to use on stainless steel surfaces. It effectively removes stains and restores the shine without scratching the surface.

Is Comet a good bathroom cleaner?

Yes, Comet is known for its effectiveness as a bathroom cleaner. It can remove soap scum, grime, and tough stains from bathroom fixtures and surfaces.

Can Comet be used on porcelain?

Yes, Comet can be used on porcelain surfaces. It helps to remove stains and restore the cleanliness of porcelain fixtures like sinks and toilets.

Which product is better for tough stains, Bar Keepers Friend or Comet?

Both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet are effective in tackling tough stains. However, Bar Keepers Friend is known for its exceptional stain-removing power on a wide range of surfaces.

Where can I buy Bar Keepers Friend and Comet?

Bar Keepers Friend and Comet can be found in most major retailers, as well as online platforms like Amazon. They are widely available for purchase.

Are there different size options available for Bar Keepers Friend and Comet?

Yes, both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet offer different size options to cater to various cleaning needs and preferences. You can choose the size that suits you best.

What do users say about Bar Keepers Friend and Comet?

Users have reported positive experiences with both Bar Keepers Friend and Comet. However, some prefer the exceptional cleaning power of Bar Keepers Friend, while others appreciate the affordability and versatility of Comet.

Which brand is the best cleaning option overall?

The best cleaning option between Bar Keepers Friend and Comet depends on your specific needs and preferences. Consider factors such as cleaning performance, suitability for surfaces, pricing, and user reviews to make an informed decision.

Check out some other posts...
Scroll to Top